Model H reproducer original vs reproduction???

[keith1954]

So, now that my Standard Model D phonograph is up and running I'd like to hear opinions on reproduction reproducers vs restored original reproducers. Right now I have a reproduction Model C, this to my ears sounds quite nice. Also with the phonograph is an original Model H reproducer that still retains much of the original green tint. Currently, there are only 5 Amberol cylinders in my collection. They all sound pretty good with the Model H. I ought to add that the stylus has been looked at with a jeweler's loupe and doesn't seem to show much wear. But I'm hardly an expert... The many Blue Amberols sound pretty good with the Model H, but not as clear or loud as they would with the proper reproducer. At this time, a dedicated Amberol machine isn't in the cards, so one capable of playing 2-4 minute cylinders will have to do.

My question is really this: do I have the original Model H restored or purchase a reproduction? Thoughts, opinions, and your experience would be appreciated.

Thanks,
Keith

[lucius1958]

Restore the original, definitely.

BillS

[keith1954]

Bill,

Thanks for the feedback. My preference is to repair or restore rather than replace with reproduction. I just wanted to hear some input from others who,most likely, know more about this subject than I do. Thanks again...

Keith

[refseries]

Dear Keith

Often a reproducer goes faint because the gaskets have failed and sound is escaping. Try sucking the end of the reproducer - if there is no vacuum, the gaskets need replacing. Many people sell new gaskets inexpensively (APSCO, eBay, Ron Sitko) and while fiddly it is a great job to do as you get instant results.

You have to undo the small screws holding the stylus bar, the hinge and the limit stop. You will need a watchmakers' screwdriver and if your eyes are as tired as mine an eyeglass. These screws can be a bit stuck after time, but benefit from a drop of penetrating oil first. The dismantling process is fairly self evident but take care not to break off the tiny screw under the hinge block as these are really hard to get out once broken.

Clean everything thoroughly and reassemble. Do not get oil on the new gaskets as some rubber ones instantly deform if you do. When you tighten up the diaphragm ring do not overtighten it or the sound will be harsh. Just tighten it until it first becomes airtight.

Have a look at the stylus with the eyeglass. If it is chipped, replace it. You can get a stylus on a bar, or send your bar to Paul Hodgson at Expert Stylus and they will fit a new one. I usually do this as their service is superb.

Good luck - you will enjoy this job!

Keith

[keith1954]

Thanks so much for the information. My magnifying glass, though rather large, isn't very powerful as the stylus is barely visible. Once I get something more powerful, I can proceed. The seal is good, however.
Thanks,
Keith